10 min read

Comparing Personal Loan, Credit Cards and HELOC: How to Find Your Best Fit

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • LinkedIn Copied link to Clipboard!

Choosing the right loan product to meet your financial needs can be confusing. With several options like Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs), personal loans, and credit cards, it's crucial to understand how each works and what scenarios they are best suited for. You might ask yourself, "What is a HELOC?" or "Which financial product is right for me?" This guide will help you answer those questions.

Young smiling couple working from home, going over paperwork Article Image
Yellow notepad with pen svg icon Lesson Notes:
  • HELOCs offer lower interest rates but require home equity.
  • Personal loans provide fixed payments without collateral requirements.
  • Credit cards offer revolving credit with higher interest rates.
  • HELOCs are flexible for ongoing expenses; loans suit one-time needs.

Understanding your financial options: Products and their uses 

Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) 

A Home Equity Line of Credit is a revolving line of credit secured by the equity accumulated in your home. It allows you to borrow as needed up to a certain limit and is often used for home renovations, debt consolidation, or covering unexpected expenses. 

Personal Loan 

A personal loan is a fixed amount borrowed from a lending financial institution, repaid over a fixed term with fixed monthly payments. It is suitable for one-time expenses such as medical bills, major purchases, or debt consolidation. 

Credit Card 

A credit card is an unsecured revolving line of credit that allows for purchases up to a set limit, with the option to pay the balance in full or over time. Consumers often use credit cards for everyday purchases, emergencies, or building credit history. 

This guide will dive into the comparisons of HELOC vs credit card, HELOC vs personal loan, and personal loan vs credit card to help you determine the best fit for your financial situation. 

HELOC vs credit card: Which is better for you? 

When comparing a HELOC vs a credit card, it's essential to consider the unique features and pros of each. 

Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) 

Benefits

  • Lower interest rates: HELOCs typically have lower interest rates relative to credit cards because they are secured by your home.
  • Potential tax benefits: If you use HELOC borrowings on home improvements, the interest paid may be tax-deductible. Please consult a tax advisor for further information regarding deductibility of interest and charges.
  • Flexibility: You can borrow as needed and only pay interest on the amount drawn.

Drawbacks

  • Collateral requirement: Your home serves as collateral, meaning “If you fall behind or can’t repay the loan on schedule, you could lose your home” (CFPB, 2024).
  • Variable interest rates: Some HELOCs have variable rates, which can lead to fluctuating payments.
  • Closing costs and fees: Potential costs might be associated with setting up a HELOC. .

Credit Card 

Benefits

  • No collateral required: Unlike a HELOC, credit cards do not require collateral.
  • Rewards: Many credit cards offer varying rewards such as cashback, points, or travel miles.
  • Revolving credit: As you repay your balance, your available credit is replenished, providing ongoing access to funds.
  • Establishing credit: Gaining added insight into the building of your credit portfolio with a revolving source.

Drawbacks

  • Higher interest rates: Credit cards generally have higher rates than HELOCs. For instance, the latest data shows rates at 21% (St. Louis Fed, 2024).
  • Risk of high-interest debt: Mismanagement can lead to significant debt accumulation.
  • Lower borrowing limits: Credit cards typically have lower credit limits than HELOCs.

When comparing a credit card vs HELOC, consider your need for flexibility, the amount you plan to borrow, and your comfort with using your home as collateral. 

HELOC vs personal loan: Making the right choice 

Choosing between a HELOC vs personal loan depends on your financial situation and needs. Key distinctions between the two are rates and collateral. As a HELOC borrower, you must be comfortable with variable or fixed interest rates and using your home equity as collateral. On the other hand, personal loans have fixed payments and require no collateral. 

A HELOC is most beneficial for homeowners with significant equity who need ongoing access to funds over an extended period. For instance, if you are planning extensive home renovations, a HELOC allows you to borrow as needed. It’s a flexible option for financing multiple phases of a project. Additionally, if you anticipate irregular expenses, such as medical bills or education costs, a HELOC avails a revolving credit line that you can access whenever necessary. Its lower interest rates than other financial products make it an attractive option for debt consolidation, particularly if you have high-interest credit card debt. 

On the other hand, a personal loan is ideal for individuals who prefer the stability of fixed monthly payments and a predetermined duration. This predictability makes personal loans suitable for one-time expenses like purchasing a vehicle, financing a wedding, or covering unexpected medical bills. The fixed interest rate and repayment schedule ensure you know exactly how much you must pay each month, making budgeting easier. 

Personal loan vs credit card: Finding your best fit 

When picking between a personal loan vs credit card, it's essential to consider several key factors: 

Interest Rates 

Personal loans generally offer lower interest rates versus credit cards. Additionally, their fixed interest rates provide predictability in monthly payments. On the other hand, credit cards typically have higher interest rates and variable rates. 

Borrowing Limits 

In terms of limits, personal loans allow for higher borrowing limits, making them suitable for significant expenses like home renovations or consolidating large amounts of debt. In contrast, credit cards have lower limits. They may not be sufficient for large one-time expenses but are convenient for everyday purchases. 

Repayment Terms 

A personal loan is the answer if you prefer fixed repayment terms and a set end date. As you pay down your balance, your available credit does not become replenished. 

Flexibility and Usage 

Personal loans are best for one-time, larger expenses that require a lump sum. However, credit cards are better for everyday purchases, emergencies, and costs that you can pay off quickly. 

Application Process 

The application process for a personal loan can be more time-consuming and require more documentation. In contrast, credit cards are easier to apply for, and you receive a decision within minutes or days. That’s why they are a popular option, with U.S. households increasing balances by $27 billion in the second quarter to $1.14 trillion outstanding (New York Fed, 2024). 

Impact on Credit Score 

Applying for a personal loan might trigger a temporary dip in your score because of a hard inquiry. However, timely repayments can improve your credit score over time. Similarly, applying for a credit card results in a hard inquiry. Responsible use and on-time payments positively impact your credit score, while high balances and missed payments can have negative effects. 

FAQs 

What are the main differences between a HELOC and a credit card? 

A HELOC is a secured line of credit using your home as collateral, offering lower interest rates and potential tax benefits. It’s suitable for multi-phased projects like home renovations or irregular expenses like education costs or medical bills. A credit card is an unsecured revolving line of credit with higher interest rates and rewards programs. They serve everyday purchases and smaller expenses better.

When should I choose a personal loan over a HELOC? 

Choose a personal loan if you prefer fixed monthly payments, do not have home equity, or do not wish to use your home as collateral. 

What factors should I consider when deciding between a personal loan and a credit card? 

  • Interest rates: Personal loans generally offer lower fixed rates, while credit cards typically have higher variable rates.
  • Repayment terms: Personal loans have fixed repayment schedules, whereas credit cards offer revolving credit with flexible payment options.
  • Borrowing limits: Personal loans usually allow for larger lump-sum amounts, while credit cards have lower credit limits.
  • Purpose of funds: Personal loans are better for large, one-time expenses; credit cards are ideal for everyday spending and emergencies.
  • Credit Impact: Both can affect your credit score, but credit cards require consistent management, including utilizing credit card tips and tricks, to avoid high balances that can negatively impact credit utilization ratios

How can a HELOC benefit me compared to other financial products? 

A HELOC offers flexibility, potentially lower interest rates, and the ability to borrow as needed up to your credit limit, making it suitable for ongoing or variable expenses. Plus, the interest paid is tax deductible if used for qualifying home improvements. Consult a tax advisor for further information regarding deductibility of interest and charges.

Citations

 

*PLEASE NOTE: This article is intended to be used for informational purposes and should not be considered financial advice. Consult a financial advisor, accountant or other financial professional to learn more about what strategies are appropriate for your situation.

Related Resources

View All