4 min read
When Is It Not Worth Repairing a Car?
-
-
Copied link to Clipboard!
If your car needs repairs, you may want to consider if it’s cost-effective to get the repairs done. In some cases, it might make more sense to trade your old car in for another vehicle instead of investing in costly repairs, especially if it is nearing the end of its working life. Choosing whether or not to repair your car depends on several factors, including the cost of repairs, how long the car will last and how much it’s worth in today’s market. Learn when to trade in your car instead of making repairs for the best money management.
Lesson Notes:
- You will have to either replace or repair your car if it breaks down.
- Buying another used car may cost more or about the same as the cost of repairs.
- It may make more financial sense to replace the car if it is on its way out or the repairs cost more than the value of a used car.
LESSON CONTENTS
When to Repair or Replace Your Car
Your car will eventually need repairs, so it’s recommended that you include this expense in your budget. Some of the most important parts and components will likely need to be replaced after 100,000 miles or more, such as the engine, battery, axels, brakes, tires, pistons and timing belts. Newer vehicles may last up to 200,000 miles if you drive them with care and keep up with regular maintenance, but your car will likely start showing signs of wear once you pass the 100,000-mile mark.
The cost of repairing these parts can be several thousand dollars or more. For example, repairing your engine can easily cost $4,000, while a new set of tires can cost $700 or more.
If your car needs extensive repairs, usually several thousand dollars or more, you may want to consider replacing the vehicle outright. You can do some quick math to compare the cost of repairs with the cost of buying a new car.
First, you’ll want to assess how much it will cost to repair your vehicle. Find a reliable mechanic that will give you an honest estimate for the repair job. Consider calling multiple repair shops to find the best rate.
Once you have an idea of how much the repairs will cost, look up the make and model of your vehicle online. You can search for listings of the same vehicle or search for your car on Kelley Blue Book to get a rough estimate of its value.
If the repair estimate is close to the value of your car or a year’s worth of car payments, consider trading it in for a new or used car to save money in the long term. Use this car affordability calculator to determine the purchase price of the vehicle you can afford with your trade-in.
Additional Factors to Consider:
There are other factors to consider when thinking about whether to make the repairs or if it’s worth going through the process of buying a car.
How Long Will the Repairs Last?
Repairing your current car may seem cheaper than buying a new or used vehicle, but it may need additional repairs in the future. Depending on the overall condition of the car, you may have to replace the vehicle in the near future, so consider replacing it before you sink more money into major repairs. Have a professional inspect your car to see if it’s in good condition other than the necessary repairs. If you can keep using your car for another few years or more, it may be worth the cost to make the repairs.
Fuel Mileage
Replacing your old car with a new one can help you save money in other ways as well. Consider how much you could save at the pump if you trade in your car for a more fuel-efficient model.
Safety
You should never drive a car that could put your safety at risk. If your car leaves you stranded or is nearing the end of its life, it’s time to sell. Your safety should be your first priority when choosing a mode of transportation. Finding a car with additional safety features may also help you lower the cost of insurance.
What to Do with a Car That’s Not Worth Repairing
If you decide it’s time to replace your car, you have several options.
If the car still has some value, you can sell it by putting it on the market. Consider listing it yourself or taking it to a used car dealership. When selling your car, you can either pay to make the necessary repairs and pay yourself back later or list the car as is and subtract the repairs estimate from the listing price. You may have an easier time selling the vehicle for a higher price if you make the repairs, especially if you know a reputable mechanic.
If you choose to keep the car as is, be upfront with the buyer about the repairs. Show them estimates from a mechanic, so they know how much it will cost to fix these issues.
If there is no value in repairing the car, consider scrapping it for parts to make some money off the vehicle. You may have to pay to have a shop impound your car if it’s no longer usable. Do your research when replacing or repairing your car to ensure that you get the best value. You don’t want to waste your money on a car that’s on its way out.
Related Resources
View All
10 min read
How Do I Refinance My Mortgage and Consolidate Debt?
Paying different credit card bills, a personal loan, and a 30-year mortgage every month can feel like managing a dozen spinning plates at once. Refinancing your home loan to combine higher-rate balances into a single, lower-rate mortgage — known as a debt consolidation refinance — transforms that juggling act into one predictable payment.
How do you refinance your mortgage for debt consolidation? We break down how a mortgage debt consolidation refinance works, when the math favors you, and how to weigh the risks and rewards.
12 min read
What are the Differences: VA Loan vs Conventional Loan
Choosing the right credit union mortgage loan shouldn’t feel like decoding a secret manual. Yet when people first compare a VA loan vs a conventional loan, the jargon — funding fees, PMI, conforming limits — can stall the search before it starts. This guide strips away the haze by lining up the two products feature by feature. You will see how each loan handles down payments, credit scores, interest rates, and closing costs, and you’ll finish with a checklist that points you toward the option most likely to fit your budget, service record, and future plans.
5 min read
Why Are Mortgage Rates So High?
If you are mortgage shopping this year, you are feeling the rate sticker shock. The average 30-year fixed rate sits around 7 percent, more than double the record lows of 2021 (Mortgage News Daily, 2025). Why are mortgage rates so high today? In short, mortgage rates are higher because the bond market — where mortgage prices are set — adjusted the cost of money. This shift came after the Federal Reserve responded to a period of high inflation. A careful look at policy, prices, and growth helps explain the surge in rates and the impact of mortgage rates on housing in 2025 and beyond.
10 min read
Can You Purchase a Car with a Credit Card?
Ask any efficiency-minded car shopper, and the first question is usually: Can you buy a car with a credit card? In theory, the answer is yes — you absolutely can. In practice, the path is littered with card-issuer rules, dealer surcharges, and interest-rate landmines that can turn a clever rewards strategy into an expensive misstep. New-vehicle prices hit an average of $48,699 in April 2025, a 2.5% month-over-month increase (Cox Automotive, 2025). At the same time, Woolsey (2025) notes the median credit card APR climbed to 24.2% in March 2025. That combination of sticker shock and swipe costs makes it vital to understand every angle before you hand the finance manager a piece of plastic.
10 min read
A Comprehensive Guide to Credit Union Home Loans in Colorado
Buying a home is one of the most significant financial decisions you'll make in your lifetime. If you're considering purchasing a home in Colorado, one of the best options is to obtain a home loan through a credit union. Why is choosing a credit union for your home loan advantageous? Learn more below, including the types of home loans in Colorado available at credit unions, how to qualify, and the step-by-step process to get you into your dream home.
10 min read
How to Qualify for a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC)
Home values continue to soar, and U.S. households have accumulated over $35 trillion in home equity (St. Louis Fed, 2024). If you are among those who have done so, you can borrow against this financial resource for various needs, such as home improvements, education expenses, or consolidating high-interest debt. Below, we outline how to qualify for a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) to prepare you for this opportunity.
12 min read
A Guide to the Different Types of Home Loans in Colorado
Purchasing a home is a dream for many. In this process, understanding the types of home loans in Colorado sets you on the right track to get a mortgage that suits you. Therefore, let's explore the various types of mortgage loans in Colorado and their benefits and eligibility requirements. You will also learn how Ent Credit Union can assist you in home-buying.
12 min read
Best Practices for Using a Home Loan Calculator in Colorado to Get Accurate Results
One of the most consequential financial decisions you will make in your lifetime is purchasing your home. In Colorado's unique housing market, using a home loan calculator in Colorado can provide invaluable insights. Read on for effective best practices in using these calculators to get accurate results.
12 min read
Taking On Your First Home Mortgage? Here's Our First-Time Homebuyer’s Guide to Home Loans
The journey to homeownership is exciting, especially for first-time buyers. However, the complexities of mortgages, understanding rates, and knowing what steps to take can sometimes become overwhelming. This guide demystifies the process of securing your first home mortgage.
8 min read
Buying a Car for the First Time
Starting your financial journey is like setting off on an exciting road trip. You’re gearing up for major life events, like buying a car for the first time. In planning for this event, remember that you are making decisions that should benefit you in the long run. Therefore, it’s important to understand the processes and the appropriate financial products to achieve your goal. This guide shows the critical steps of purchasing your first car.
7 min read
Choose the Right Mortgage Refinance Plan
Is refinancing the right move for me? It depends. Refinancing your mortgage loan can be a strategic financial move, saving you money on interest, lowering your monthly payments or shortening your term.
12 min read
Documents for Refinancing a Mortgage: A Comprehensive Guide
Refinancing a mortgage offers a pathway to adjust your financial burdens by changing the terms of your home loan in Colorado. There are several reasons for refinancing (Freddie Mac, 2024), including lowering your interest rate, reducing your monthly payment or changing the mortgage term. Other common reasons include switching from an adjustable rate to a fixed rate or tapping into your home equity. However, the process involves gathering and submitting several refinance documents. Here’s a guide to help you understand what you'll need to provide to refinance your mortgage.